The core tenet of games is the ability to inhabit other worlds. They allow us to step out of the banal drudgery of everyday existence and into the shoes of a New York gangster, a dragon-slaying hero, or a star-sailing space marine. And very occasionally, she’s a girl.
To most male gamers – the one’s I’ve talked to, at least – the idea of playing as a woman is more alien than the fantasy environments they reside in (or indeed, the aliens). After all, RPG characters tend to be completely customisable and not to have spoken dialogue because they represent a blank slate, a template onto which players can project themselves. That character being a different gender makes them completely unrelatable.
Well, while women also seem to prefer playing as women, they’re batting in a completely different ballpark. The rarity of female player characters in games is such that playing a female character, apart from anything else, makes such a welcome change. RPGs’ unique capacity to shape that character’s journey only increases the sense of fighting gaming’s gender inequality.
In almost every RPG I play, from Fallout to Dragon Age to the Elder Scrolls saga, my character of choice is female. I’d always had a loose notion of why, but never really delved deep enough to formulate a proper argument. Allow me to introspect.
It was always more immediately understandable to people that I’d play as Female Shepard in the Mass Effect series to avoid staring at a man’s arse for tens of hours. And I won’t deny that the player characters I craft – and often the defaults the game provides – ascribe to my own standards of beauty. They are attractive, though revealing armour annoys me to the point that I’ll try to mod it out.
I think you could say the same thing about men’s male characters. Games are fantasies. Nobody populates their fantasies with ‘average’ or ‘ugly’ looking people unless they intend to intentionally subvert notions of attractiveness. As an example, a deformed Shepard seducing his or her crew-mates is some people’s idea of fun. And I get that. You have that choice.
What nobody could rightly accuse anyone of is playing a female character for the sexual content. That won’t stop some from trying, but there has to be a general admission that even the most lovingly crafted and unfettered exploits come off as comical or awkward, and are more often completionist, part of experiencing everything a game has to offer. Self-instigated restraint has given us a few choice, believable relationships, culminating for me in the heart-rending exchanges following Mass Effect 2’s Lair of the Shadow Broker, but game relationships in general are curios, not HBO-esque TV titillation.
The best ones do at least service the narrative. The Witcher 2 reins in the excesses of its predecessor to give us scenes suited to the story and world. Mass Effect, as noted, generally succeeds in providing personal exchanges and emotional context against a greater backdrop – the greatest of them all – of galactic annihilation. And it’s that narrative of the games which gives me the greatest thrill and resonance.
For the people who project themselves onto their characters, options are limited. You are driven to act by your own reasoning and inflict your own standards. I see myself more as an observer. I’m not crafting my story, I’m creating a character’s. And in a sphere of media and a genre so reliant on the young male as a tortured paragon in a troubled world, creating a character which conflicts with conventions makes for a far more satisfying game experience.
It’s a fine line to tread. Am I besting the narrative’s sexism, or indulging my own ideas about gender roles? Is a strong and intelligent female knight or warrior so fantastical? How do I know the conventions of a universe I haven’t explored yet? I’m not sure I can give you a good answer.
Certainly going into a game like Oblivion or Fallout 3, you feel that the women of those worlds will be subjugated, or preyed on. That’s my societal bias applied to a fantasy environment that, truly, does not and should not need to be like that.
Books have oft been criticised for using high fantasy as an excuse for misogyny, and you can make the same accusation here. But those prejudices tend to hold true. Fallout may not press gender bias on you, but prostitution and slavery still exhibit the characteristics of a world we know all too well. Building the character of the Lone Wanderer, and hearing Three Dog echo your triumphs through abandoned halls, feels to me like that little bit more of an achievement.
It feels like she’s beaten the odds.
That all feeds into the general perception that heroism isn’t for girls. Men are expected to pick up the baton, to trudge off to war and into the wilderness with nary a hope, on the face of it, of returning alive. I’d like to see more emotion on the part of male characters, don’t get me wrong. But because women tend not to have the same constraints, you’re granted such imaginative scope for their reasoning and rationale. If they choose to fight, what are they trying to achieve? If they’re forced to, how do they react and reconcile that with their old life? In an ideal world they shouldn’t be valid questions, but they always seem apt.
As much as the character’s role in a given story intrigues me, there is also that story’s role among RPGs. I play a lot of games, though not half as fast as I buy them. 90% of the lead characters are male. And you know, I sometimes think, how would a female character react in this situation? What would Spec Ops: The Line be like if it reflected the new U.S. military front line? I actively seek out games like The Longest Journey and Beyond Good and Evil because they provide a different insight and approach into game storytelling, and perhaps less reassuringly, game mechanics. Or at least, I hope they will.
Maybe they shouldn’t. Maybe I’m looking for differences in the writing and construction where there are none. But it’s hard to tell when the sample size is so small. I will happily romance an interesting male character, as I did with Garrus, but the majority of male romance options – Carth, Sky, Alistair – are among a small set of BioWare games. And the inclusion of women in RPGs is often not without its caveats. There are too many games which still cast women as class-specific, the healers or mages, or which provide certain predatory bonuses over men, that they might woo the average punter into playing them. This clearly needs to stop.
I sure as hell don’t want to boil it down to romance. That’s an evolution which will come naturally as games develop, and it has little and less to do with my inclination for a more interesting story. Relationships are a component part of enormous tales and worlds where every NPC is a new variable.
Admittedly there are games where my playing as a woman is perhaps more gratuitous and indulgent. It’s the same base attraction that’s characterised recent female-led action movies, games like Bayonetta, or the legions of MMO players for whom it rubs in victory that little bit more. But I like to think that my choosing female characters reflects the biases, the shortcomings and the limited triumphs of role-playing games. I like to think that I’m better than all that. Perhaps I’m not.
Header image by DeviantArt user Maddithong.
