Review: Bioshock Infinite (PC)

I read something yesterday, casually clicking through Twitter profiles, which really made me think. It was a short blog post by former Edge editor Margaret Robertson, years old, about a bitesize impressions column she’d just started. “Review a game? You mean a part of it, surely. No-one could review a game all herself. There is just so much going on there, so many thousands of interesting design choices to talk about, so many experiences to share. I’m simply not equal to the task of reviewing a whole game any more.”

Games reviews are hard. Professional games reviews are harder. You have a handful of days to complete and assess a work of fiction, a universe of a million component parts. Player agency and your connection with the characters are strengthened over tens of hours. The result, with a narrative driven title, is that an expedient review becomes an emotional outpouring, reliving the memorable moments and revelling primarily, dangerously, in the delivery of the story.

With Bioshock Infinite, it’s not hard to see why. This isn’t a GTA IV or a Modern Warfare 2 or a Skyrim (we can argue about that later). It truly borders on being the best of its trilogy. But the pay-off of a masterful story seems, for many, to have masked the weaknesses and arguable failures in its gameplay.

infinite founding fathers

For the uninitiated, Infinite follows ex-US Cavalryman turned PI and walking cliché Booker De Witt, as he searches for his latest client’s quarry, a young woman called Elizabeth. Ferried to a familiar looking lighthouse, he is unwittingly propelled into the floating city of Columbia: an idol-worshipping, quasi-futuristic utopia. Think Skyward Sword in reverse, if Skyloft was populated entirely by racists.

The opening sequence is a more breathtaking and mystifying introduction than even the bathysphere managed. You emerge into a prototypical paradise, a flourishing city as yet unblemished by Rapture’s political turmoil. Statues of the Founding Fathers flank your passage from tranquil gardens through into streets bedecked for ceremony. You initially find yourself disoriented as buildings bob like buoys in a misty sea, moored by bridges or enacting slow commutes to other islands.

Visually, Infinite is a blinder. The city has the warm radiance of a watercolour painting, with neoclassical architecture almost cartoonishly rendered, imposingly unreal. As with their predecessors, light and shadow are everything in Infinite, and they are stunningly cast. But the general atmosphere of the opening exchanges owes itself to much more. Most NPCs are voiced and react to your presence, so that wandering along otherwise barren promenades becomes a compulsive sideshow. Everyone seems friendly, even when I’m openly pilfering from tills and hampers. But conversation snippets feed into an increasing sense of unease.

bioshock-infinite-murder-crows-vigor

As the status of your target becomes clearer, and kinetoscopes shed a little light on Columbia’s history (or just advertise – “Minor Victory…the only cigarette brand designed especially for kids!”), you feel increasingly isolated and stigmatised. Distant echoes of ‘Goodnight Irene’ take on an impossibly sinister tone as you progress further through the carnival. There is a sense of wilfully walking into disaster.

This is something of a running theme. Where the first game graced you with an illusion of control, here there is none. Booker always seems out of his depth, out of the loop. Every major decision is taken with a sense of resignation. His character grows in stature, but the arbiter of information, the crux on which every development relies, is Elizabeth.

This – she – is a marvellous piece of AI work. Alyx Vance should be flattered to be mentioned in tandem. Stop to rummage through bins and she will scamper off, to be found peering through windows or buying candyfloss. Stop to look at something and she’ll sit down or lean against a nearby wall. Her movement is reactive, skipping ahead in anticipation of your path. Bumping into her, I almost made to apologise.

The fluidity and unerring realism of motion are encapsulated by a Disney princess-esque sense of wonder. There are moments which are as good as stolen from Tangled – she genuinely runs off to Irish dance with the locals when you first rescue her – but the sense of wonder upon escaping lifelong confinement is more palpable, more believable. Superb voice acting and scripting truly ingraciate you to the character, more so than Booker ever manages. The early exchanges, in general, reflect a developer on full form.

infinite elizabeth dancing

As the story twists and contorts, however, we see her limitations. A perma-scowl when she’s unhappy, only to be punctuated by tearfully reviving you in battle, or a chirpy flip of a coin in your direction. She stands facing slightly away from you, arms folded. I’ve seen this championed in videos as a subtle reflection of feeling, but too often those feelings seem out of step with the narrative.

For good or ill, combat steps in to reinvigorate her character. With unprecedented open environments, cover is key, and her persistent presence enhances it to no end. Edge dangerously close to death and she will interject, throwing a medkit from the periphery. Ammo and salts, to top up your powers, are likewise a mere button tap and head tilt away. They are infrequent enough to still require resource management, but often so timely as to be lifesaving. Shouts as she scavenges, off-screen and mid-battle, might easily be distracting, but only ratchet up the tension in surprisingly tough set pieces.

The challenge isn’t always gratifying. Vigor upgrades seem disproportionately expensive, making weapon upgrades preferential. Early powers prove adept at crowd control, but later fights frequently include boss types whose singular weakness only ever relates to weapons.

A lack of heft or range in damage-dealing vigors relegated them to simple stuns, with firing from range and behind cover the name of the game. With this in mind, the sniper rifle and carbine become indispensable, and limited as you are to two guns at a time, a persistent fixture throughout the game. Little is likely to change your mind; guns are poorly balanced, too often crippled by a low ammo capacity, and in the case of the rebel Vox weapons, hopelessly underpowered.

bioshock-infinite-comstoc-exhibit

Any interesting avenues for combat in the open areas are soon quelled by another boss archetype. The skyrails, impossibly confusing when travelling between areas, are initially a joy in combat. Infrequent gear upgrades (including, brilliantly, melee pants) eventually add effects including knockdowns and setting enemies on fire when landing, lending to frantic firefights, leaping at and launching enemies off patrol ships before zipping off around the map. The circular route around a battlefield lends a tactical aspect to the rollercoaster traversal, jumping down into cover or picking up a downed enemy’s RPG.

Where this falls down is how enemies operate. Rather than sheltering in fixed locations, groups of soldiers will aim to rush and mob you. Powers can be laid as traps, but multiple avenues for approach make this difficult. You have an ever-present vigor shield, but it is easily broken, and on hard a handful of enemies will quickly flank and obliterate you.

Bosses similarly go straight for the jugular. The Patriot will stroll towards you or just as happily sit behind any traps you have laid, firing from afar. The mammoth Handyman meanwhile can not only jump between levels and stages, but will grab and electrocute the skyrails. Throw in snipers, rocketeers and artillery, and your safest bet is simply to snipe from cover and move.

Promised stage manipulation is disappointingly shallow. Elizabeth’s touted power to summon objects is limited to ammo crates, cover, turrets, and hooks to attach to and jump from. Using the hooks tends to get you killed faster, and advancing to worse cover than you currently occupy, faster still. Late additions include pools of water and oil, but their effect is negligible, and the maps are so big that luring ever-moving enemies onto them is a pointless endeavour.

bioshock-infinite-comstock-statue

A few stages suddenly deprive you of cover, notably a couple of unexpected boss fights, which if you’ve discarded your trusty two weapons, can become almost impossible above normal difficulty. Run out of money to revive, and you start at the beginning of the chapter; there are no manual saves.

By the time combat starts to grate, however, you’ll probably have been sucked into the all-consuming vortex of a conclusion. If your impact on the world seems limited at the start, the final two hours or so represent a fairground ride, a whirlwind of intense set pieces and plot resolutions, constantly shifting to the next location with little time to reflect on the task you’re undertaking. It’s mentally, almost physically exhausting, and the final revelations emotionally shattering. This is one way to answer accusations of a weak ending.

Old ground is retread repeatedly; hyped characters – the Songbird, the Boy of Silence – experience disappointing cameos.   The story, in turns controversial and dizzyingly bonkers, will emerge into decades of debate. But the delivery is of an auteur, a craft perfected. It may not be as flawlessly executed as the great pantheon of film, television or novels, or as original in the concepts it explores. But the tale it weaves, the questions and the challenges it poses, deserve to be enshrined in the very highest tier.

5 comments

  1. To quote the wisdom of Steve: “You’re an idiot.” I don’t say that because it’s apt, but as a friendly reminder that 100% of the feedback you get is negative and hostile. (If not for my vigilance, the number would have been halved.)

    I’m here, so let’s play your game, Bullock:

    This – she – is a marvellous piece of AI work.

    Have you ever tried shooting her just to see what happens? I couldn’t; she’s too well designed as a character and companion. How dare games trigger my natural inhibition to avoid harming other humans, right?

    Vigor upgrades seem disproportionately expensive, making weapon upgrades preferential.

    I’ve looked at the machine that sells vigors (I admire Irrational’s ability to inject character into pretty much anything. Also, veni vidi vigor: I came, I saw, I vigored. Love that shit) and it says, “choose wisely.” The upgrades are significant enough for the price to be fair, and there are half as many upgrades for the vigors as there are for weapons. If you look at the full cost for a weapon and a vigor, you’ll see that the prices are balanced. Cost of all carbine and heater upgrades respectively: 1531, 2327. Cost of all bronco and crows upgrades respectively: 1198, 2030.

    Early powers prove adept at crowd control, but later fights frequently include boss types whose singular weakness only ever relates to weapons.

    Which is fair, otherwise the game would be a cakewalk. I just beat Bioshock 1. You know what damage plasmids do to big daddies? Jack shit. The whole point of using plasmids during the fight is to hopefully stunlock the fucker and keep him as far away from you as possible.

    Any interesting avenues for combat in the open areas are soon quelled by another boss archetype.

    Unless it’s the patriot, whose attacks function as suppressive fire, then frankly it’s your fault for being complacent hiding in a corner across the map, sniping people. I was able to utilize the openness of the battlefield as well as the sky rails to annihilate everything on the move. This is especially true for the handyman, who demands the use of the same strategy used for a big daddy: “keep him as far away from you as possible.” The most exhilarating fights that had me frantically running/sky-railing around the entire area involved a handyman. Try sniping from a sky rail. Not only is it a versatile sniping position, but it’s an “interesting avenue for combat.” If that doesn’t give you a boner, then to make things interesting, stop using the cheapest weapon in the game.

    Powers can be laid as traps, but multiple avenues for approach make this difficult.

    Agreed. In fact, I’ll go as far as to say that traps are useless. Rapture had an enclosed, claustrophobic environment, conducive to trap laying (hence the trap bolts), while Columbia has long range sniping positions.

    Neat quoting system you have here, though I wish I could preview my comment as well.

  2. Shame the quoting system doesn’t work within comments. I’ll address things point by point:

    Have you ever tried shooting her just to see what happens? I couldn’t; she’s too well designed as a character and companion. How dare games trigger my natural inhibition to avoid harming other humans, right?

    You lower your weapon when it’s aimed at her, so I always assumed it wouldn’t let you fire.

    I’ve looked at the machine that sells vigors (I admire Irrational’s ability to inject character into pretty much anything. Also, veni vidi vigor: I came, I saw, I vigored. Love that shit) and it says, “choose wisely.” The upgrades are significant enough for the price to be fair, and there are half as many upgrades for the vigors as there are for weapons.

    It’s not just the pricing; for me, the whole way vigors worked put me off using them. In the first Bioshock, powers had practical applications – lighting oil, electrocuting pools, throwing back grenades, etc. There wasn’t any of that to tempt me into using them. They were touted as being more fun than the original and they just weren’t. The only tangible use they seemed to have was crowd control and short stuns; even with the stuns, I found they weren’t long enough to manoeuvre around a Patriot, say, to get damage off. Perhaps they were more powerful than I give them credit for, but the upgrades didn’t appear to me to justify saving and not spending on guns, which I used more often and to greater effect.

    Which is fair, otherwise the game would be a cakewalk. I just beat Bioshock 1. You know what damage plasmids do to big daddies? Jack shit. The whole point of using plasmids during the fight is to hopefully stunlock the fucker and keep him as far away from you as possible.

    Yeah, but you were able to keep a variety of weapons which actually made running around, stunning and shooting the things viable. It was also always just you vs the big daddy, not you being sniped and blown up while it romps up to you. Leaving cover in Infinite tended to mean getting nailed by flak, and those guys were armoured as much as the fucking Patriots.

    Unless it’s the patriot, whose attacks function as suppressive fire, then frankly it’s your fault for being complacent hiding in a corner across the map, sniping people. I was able to utilize the openness of the battlefield as well as the sky rails to annihilate everything on the move. This is especially true for the handyman, who demands the use of the same strategy used for a big daddy: “keep him as far away from you as possible.” The most exhilarating fights that had me frantically running/sky-railing around the entire area involved a handyman. Try sniping from a sky rail. Not only is it a versatile sniping position, but it’s an “interesting avenue for combat.” If that doesn’t give you a boner, then to make things interesting, stop using the cheapest weapon in the game.

    My Handyman strategy consisted of using all the skyrail items, shooting it until it jumped up to electrocute the rails, drop down and then rinse and repeat. I just think there was room to use vigors and weapons more tactically against bosses. Instead all of the tactics were in the environments, and frankly, I was generally dissuaded from leaving cover by the amount I would get shot at. When using the skyrails against armoured opponents, jumping down, setting them on fire, shooting them did sweet bugger all, and then they’d blow me up. Jumping on and off the skyrail to stun and shoot something before it gets up did not strike me as tactical or particularly fun.

    Agreed. In fact, I’ll go as far as to say that traps are useless. Rapture had an enclosed, claustrophobic environment, conducive to trap laying (hence the trap bolts), while Columbia has long range sniping positions.

    Trap bolts did break the game a bit, but they were fun, and they allowed you to plan ahead for confrontations. Every fight in Infinite is a battle, you start behind cover and then things run at you, or snipe you. It just didn’t seem very multi-layered; sniping was often the safest and most effective way of proceeding. I tried zipping around, taking enemies on at closer range, but I didn’t have the weapons for it, and when I used the shotgun and other close range weapons, I found them lacking. ‘Use a less Op weapon’ doesn’t detract from the fact that some weapons are OP and some are useless. The way vigors and weapons are gradually introduced, and the way upgrades work, completely dissuaded me from trying new ones.

  3. It’s not just the pricing; for me, the whole way vigors worked put me off using them. In the first Bioshock, powers had practical applications – lighting oil, electrocuting pools, throwing back grenades, etc. There wasn’t any of that to tempt me into using them. They were touted as being more fun than the original and they just weren’t. The only tangible use they seemed to have was crowd control and short stuns; even with the stuns, I found they weren’t long enough to manoeuvre around a Patriot, say, to get damage off. Perhaps they were more powerful than I give them credit for, but the upgrades didn’t appear to me to justify saving and not spending on guns, which I used more often and to greater effect.

    You know what, fuck the water and the oil, what the game is missing is good old telekinesis. The closest thing to that is sender aid and it’s given at the end. A shame, but it does make you godlike.

    Yeah, but you were able to keep a variety of weapons which actually made running around, stunning and shooting the things viable. It was also always just you vs the big daddy, not you being sniped and blown up while it romps up to you. Leaving cover in Infinite tended to mean getting nailed by flak, and those guys were armoured as much as the fucking Patriots.

    This is why I incessantly keep saying that the weapon limit is bullshit. Did part of their “appeal to casual frats” strategy involve turning the game into CoD? I see no reason for the limitation other than adhering to shitty FPS conventions.

    Use a less Op weapon’ doesn’t detract from the fact that some weapons are OP and some are useless. The way vigors and weapons are gradually introduced, and the way upgrades work, completely dissuaded me from trying new ones.

    Again, the fault lies with you. The alternative weapons aren’t useless, you just don’t like using anything other than the most efficient killer. The repeater, for example, is a pretty decent assault rifle. It’s better than the machine gun because of the lower firing rate (for ammo conservation) and higher damage. Angry Joe recommends using the volley gun for patriots. Other people seem to be doing just fine not using the sniper rifle the entire time. In fact, I call the carbine master race; it’s more versatile than the sniper. I focused on two weapons as well, but it’s not because the game discourages experimentation (I tried out every new weapon; the bullshit weapon limit and low ammo supply also forced me to use others), it just discourages buying weapon upgrades for everything. Even then, having the right gear and vigor upgrades can be tolerable substitutes for weapon upgrades. I’ll gladly use different weapons in later playthroughs.

    Here’s to hoping I coded my response properly so it doesn’t look like I’m arguing with myself.

    1. I’m not saying all of the other guns are useless, just that there are too many of them which are inferior, and a lot introduced late game when you have no incentive to use them. Finding a new weapon in a game should be a ‘wow’ moment; it should look cool and have some unique property. I’m tempted to say that Infinite has too many guns, but they are generally boring to use and to look at. With the tech Columbia has, I was expecting something more conceptual, more interesting than the usual array of carbine, machine gun, shotgun, etc. I did also use a multitude of weapons because of ammo limits, and sure, the repeater is better than the machine gun, because the machine gun isn’t very good. The volley gun became my second weapon late on when I ran out of carbine ammo. But there is still an evident lack of weapon balance, and when every fight is a giant, tough setpiece, I didn’t want to lose my good weapons just to experiment.

  4. Alex
    I’m tempted to say that Infinite has too many guns

    I’ll do it for you: there are too many guns, with very little distinction between them. Which leads us back to the main culprit behind all these problems: the bullshit two weapon limit. It’s amazing that with most of its focus on action, Infinite still managed degrade the quality of the combat compared to the standard set by its predecessor. I agree with Alec Meer of RPS, who said of the weapons: “there isn’t much to distinguish between them on a level beyond long range, short range and rapid-fire explosions.” Rather than having different ammo types, the game duplicated weapon types. This is just another example of how sacrificing the conventions of a series for those more familiar to casuals is detrimental to the overall experience.

    One more point: John Teti writes,

    John TetiOther parts of the BioShock carryover simply don’t make sense. It’s all well and good that the plasmids of the old game have been rechristened as Vigors for Infinite, but in the BioShock, plasmid abuse was an integral part of Rapture’s downfall. More to the point, plasmids made sense in the culture of Rapture, where self-worship was the norm, and man’s freedom to improve his lot was sacrosanct. Where do Vigors fit into Columbia? I don’t know, and neither does Infinite. There are advertisements for Vigors all over the city, and you can find bottles of the stuff lying around, but very few Columbians use them. In a society that espouses racial purity, you’d think Vigors would be more of an issue. After all, they can turn a person into a demigod regardless of race. But this never comes up. If anything, Comstock appears to tacitly embrace the sale of Vigors. There’s a difference between plot holes, which are excusable, and a disregard for internal logic. Vigors belong to the latter category.

    Considering the amount of detail packed into the game’s environment and lore, this is a disappointing oversight.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *