Sir Isaac Newton was a prescient sort of chap. When he laid down his Third Law – that every action has an equal and opposite reaction – he hadn’t just defined a physical constant, but a social one. Praise or hate, affirm or deny, the internet has never been more liable to knock down your door and tell you just how wrong you are.
Permit me a paragraph on Frozen. Frozen was well reviewed; it won two Oscars; tried to iterate on the Tangled template with a new slant on the happily ever after story. It has been enjoyed by millions of people. Critically, objectively, personally: Frozen is not a bad film. Would you have guessed it lately? From Facebook to the most tenuously related articles, there is nothing left but scorn. By Youtube’s reckoning, every Disney song ever uploaded is better than Let it Go. What might have started as ‘it’s not as good as everyone says it is’ has snowballed and amplified into outright hatred.
Let’s roll back the clock. A modest sci-fi brawler comes out a week before The Last of Us, and shortly before the announcement of the next-gen consoles at E3. The reviews are mixed to positive, and it doesn’t sell very well. Come the next Steam sale, enough people take a chance on it to start a groundswell of goodwill. When a new game is announced from the same studio, the comments under each article gush with praise, railing against the review scores: a sprinkling of legitimate public service, a pinch of ‘I’ve played this and I want everyone to know about it’, and a knowing dash of exaggeration. The cumulative effect is to make an okay game appear to have been undermined, and exactly what everyone was always looking for.
I’m pleased that DONTNOD are making another game, honest. There was promise in Remember Me. But to defend something on the grounds that it’s not as bad as everyone made out is a sure sign that it is exactly as bad as everyone made out; you simply feel that its innate badness does not fairly reflect the whole experience. Remember Me is not a terrible game, true enough, but was it fun? I reviewed it at launch, and I didn’t think so. The professionals generally didn’t think so. You can endow a game with all the pretty music and stellar art direction you like, but if the combat is that weightless and grindy, the key combo mechanic that undercooked, the voice acting and dialogue that bad, the best mechanic underused, there is only so much you can excuse. In short, you cannot recommend a game that isn’t fun to play.
Pending successor Life is Strange is highly commendable: a unique new IP with characters outside the cookie cutter mould, when large releases from small studios seemed unsustainable. But for their sake, stop pretending that the first outing was a more accomplished game than it was. I want the next one to be a whole lot better.
