Antisocial justice warriors

As a male human attempting to write a dissertation on gender issues in games, I am, as you may already have identified, a colossal prick.

I’m also tasked with encapsulating and explaining the public discourse on women in games. This would be a whole lot easier if any such thing existed.

There are lots of articles. Rock Paper Shotgun issued one just yesterday. We’re still getting GDC coverage: that mecca for unbridled and unfounded optimism, a congregation of developers pissing into the winds of publisher power. But discourse is rather cunningly defined by conversation; multiple sides, differing opinions.

There seems to be a tacit acceptance within what remains of the game gender debate, ignited some two years ago now, that the conversation is over. ‘Social justice warrior’ is now the comment section calling card of the anti lobby, a trite little exercise in sweeping generalisations. The ‘SJWs’ themselves continue to churn out articles for their captive audience, but if the authors don’t turn off the comments on their articles, they sure as hell don’t read them. There’s a dividing line down the internet, and ignorance prevails.

You can trace it all back to that article by John Walker. It’s a declaration of war as written by Neville Chamberlain. The thing is, if you’re declaring war, it doesn’t make a jizzing difference how considered and rational your argument is: you’re drawing battle lines, and whomsoever finds themself on the other side is forever lost to you. I agree with Walker in broad strokes, and the author of that widely-circulated ‘do not read’ list of SJW journalists missed a tremendous interview yesterday. But his proclamation was profoundly stupid.

I understand the logic behind it. It does seem, sometimes, that there is just no reasoning with people. It’s the great oxymoron of the internet: how can a platform which is technically so adept at bringing people together be so inept for communication? I don’t think it’s insurmountable. There will come a time where we actually converse, when speech and all its nuance stops being the preserve of the vlog and arranged conference call, and starts being how we all ‘socially network’. It may come at the cost of anonymity, but that already seems an inevitability for different reasons.

Until then, we have to make the effort. Especially as writers. I have never wholly understood the mentality that drives people to avoid comments on their work. People don’t always know what’s best for you and your writing, never assume that. But you’re writing for an audience. How can you then ignore them and say they don’t matter? Why would you wilfully lose sight of what people want to see?

People have legitimate concerns, even if they are misguided: issues of censorship, forced romance and token characters, money problems and viability, absurd arbitrary quotas like establishing a 50/50 gender split in development. Do you have any fucking idea how ironic it is to close comments in that situation, to self-censor and isolate yourself to a niche that’ll say nice things?

Forgo feedback and you lose all claims to authority. How can anyone trust that you’re on the right side of an argument when it’s the only one you’ll court?

And sure, a website’s registered community isn’t always representative of the general reader. But you’re still a slave to them, in a certain respect. They drive the bulk of your traffic. They are the public face of that site. If they’re not saying nice things, at least take a moment to understand why. You might learn something in the process; if not about yourself and your writing, then about the people you are ultimately writing it for.

That doesn’t have to mean compromising your ‘artistic integrity’. If you want to write something, don’t not do it because you think a few people won’t be receptive. But you get to have your cake and eat it. Play both sides. Find a way to work their reception into your next article. Do what you want to do in a way people can’t complain about. Respond to those comments. Be snarky, take the piss, whatever. At least show that you’re in tune with the readership, that you represent them on some level. I guarantee you, respond to the  comment trolls on a major site, they’ll stop commenting.

Such is writers’ hatred of comment sections, people post horrible things in the expectation that they won’t be read. They become an extension of every internet forum where you can say anything without reprisal. Don’t fear the comments — take them back.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *