Fantasy Premier League Guide 23/24

fantasy premier league 23-24 banner

Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose. That’s right: the constant, dizzying, 24-hour, year-long action is back, and fantasy football is back with it. Enjoy my attempts to justify my team selection and non-selections below, as I inevitably careen into a week two wildcard. I finished top 2.5k once, you know.

Goalkeepers

Last year’s breakout strategy of juggling two 4.0m keepers failed fairly spectacularly, as many people quickly transitioned away from the hapless Ward/Iversen combo to His Excellence Nick Pope the 1st, and onto the Man of Steele. The potential for a similar strat seems limited this year anyway, with no obvious 4.0 standouts, so the usual dilemma returns: 4.5m budget or 5-5.5m premium?

The most expensive keepers are rarely worth it, as Ederson and Allison from last year would attest. The genuinely good defences tend to limit the save point potential of their keepers, and usually stout defences such as City’s proved unreliable last year anyway. The best keepers are those that combine decent CS potential with a high number of saves, such as the aforementioned Pope.

In a field with few standout options, Man Utd’s Onana (5.0m) could be a candidate for this crown this year. Kepa (5.0m) is reasonably priced but takes a valuable Chelsea spot, and will face competition from Sanchez (4.5m). Sa (5.0m) is a dangerous gamble given how poorly Wolves have invested so far, while Ramsdale (5.0m) may also be troubled by the arrival of David Raya (5.0m). Pope is a tad overpriced this year, and Newcastle are likely to be challenged by their busy European schedule, as well as tough opening fixtures.

Martinez (5m) hasn’t quite looked the same since the World Cup, and I feel is overpriced compared to the Villa defenders, who offer some attacking threat. Fabianski (4.5m) is getting on and could be challenged by Areola (4m), who is a very solid backup, and one to keep an eye on. Vicario (5m) is to be avoided for now, while I don’t like either of Leno or Neto (4.5m)’s fixtures (or indeed prospects).

Pickford and Johnstone (4.5m) may present interesting mid table options, with Palace in particular benefitting from a kind start to the season. Verbruggen (4.5m) is tempting, but has looked somewhat shaky in pre-season. I would also be inclined to save the third Brighton spot for attackers given De Zerbi’s philosophy, as well as their opening fixtures; it’s very easy to envisage starting GW1 with three of Mitoma, Ferguson, Joao Pedro and Estupinan.

Defenders

Speaking of Estupinan, it feels like him and four more this season in defence. The 5.0m price tag – cheaper than many lesser performing players – seems absurdly low given his consistent attacking and defensive contributions last year. Indeed, this season feels like a fresh start for the fullback meta, after a disappointingly paltry haul from the likes of James, Chilwell, Robertson and Trent last year, as well as late season Trippier.

Trent at 8m to me is a strange one: a price increase based entirely on his movement into midfield, rather than on the evidence of his performances. For all its been heralded as a tactical master stroke and a boon for FPL players, I’m not sure the deep-lying midfield role enhances his attacking potential that much, and Liverpool look as weak at the back as ever. This is the one year I think it’s absolutely justifiable not to have him or Robertson in your XI, just based on how many other ways there are to spend that money.

One Chelsea fullback seems like the most reliable investment in a Chelsea team likely to post big attacking returns, but without a nailed down attacking line. Chilwell (5.5m) is my preference just based on James’ recurrent injuries, although neither is particularly reliable. Brace yourselves, but I think there’s also a reasonable argument to be made for Pedro Porro (5m) at Spurs. We saw his goalscoring potential in brief flashes last season, and while pre-season suggests they will not be keeping many clean sheets, the fullbacks are being encouraged to bomb forwards at will.

With even the best two defences in the league proving unreliable last year, and Newcastle suffering a tough run of games, there are few obvious centreback picks. Again, I feel the usual strategy here is the safe one: chase goalscoring potential, mediated against potential defensive returns. The best picks there are Arsenal players, and the likeliest scorer and best all-round player for me is Saliba (5m), as I think Gabriel (5m) is under more pressure from Kiwior (4.5m), and White (5.5m) may face competition from Tomiyasu (4.5m). Van Dijk (6m) isn’t a bad pick and has looked sharper in pre-season, but is 0.5m overpriced in my view.

Bargain hunters and enabler enjoyers should look no further than Issa Kaboré (4m). Luton are unlikely to notch many clean sheets, but they will try, and the 22-year-old City loanee has two seasons of Ligue 1 football under his belt, as well as a Young Player of the Tournament award from the 2021 Afcon, making him a likely starter. Keep tabs on where Lamptey (4m) ends up, and don’t look past the array of excellent 4.5m assets either. Botman, Cash, and Henry are all routes into solid teams with attacking potential, though I’d wait to see who triumphs out of Pau Torres, Mings and Konsa before investing more heavily in the Villa defence.

Midfielders

Choosing a midfield five is as difficult and exciting as it has been in years. A major pricing shakeup (and some underwhelming premium assets) has seen the onus shift from the usual stalwarts to a range of mercurial, mid-priced options. As well as the entire Arsenal midfield – all excellent value at 7-8.5m – assets such as Foden, Grealish, Rashford, Bruno, Maddison, Havertz, Son, Jota and Diaz are all competing in the sub-premium bracket.

There are a few standouts here for me. Rashford (9m) is an obvious pick while his good form holds, though there’s a strong argument to be made for Bruno (8.5m), with the addition of Hojlund providing a finisher for the ample chances he creates. Saka (8.5m) is a must-have, and there’s a solid case for repeating the favoured Arsenal double-up with Martinelli (8m) too, who for me is the most natural finisher of their front players. Trossard (7m) could be terrific value, but wait to see who takes Jesus’ spot.

With City, I would opt for Foden (7.5m) over Grealish (7.5m), who has been playing regularly in pre-season, has better potential for hauls, and looks set for more starts this year. Both are preferable to De Bruyne (10.5m) in my mind, who while cheaper this year, is increasingly troubled by injuries, and liable to be rotated more often. I also wouldn’t blame anyone for holding fire on all of them, and trading down an Arsenal or United asset once we have a better idea of which City players are getting the most minutes.

Liverpool are a major conundrum this year, both in midfield and attack. Six players jostling for three positions makes it difficult to recommend anyone. Luis Diaz could be great value at 7.5m, and should start far more often after an injury-hit campaign, but Diogo Jota (8m) has also shown excellent form, both in pre-season and at the end of the last one. Salah (12.5m) remains the likeliest to start, but I’m not sure his price is justified given the potential for goals to be shared around, particularly with Darwin and Gakpo operating as more orthodox 9s (screenshot this for later).

Maddison and Havertz (7.5m) are both wait-and-sees for me. While Havertz could benefit from the absence of Jesus, it’s much more likely that one of Trossard or Martinelli (8m) will replace him, given Havertz’ previous struggles as a false 9. Maddison is less an issue with the player and more an issue with the club, given that Postecoglou’s teams typically get off to a slow start, and the future of Kane is still unresolved. I am however a long-standing Son stan, and having recovered from an injury he was carrying all of last season, I won’t be surprised if he resumes his usual form. He’s my Spurs attacking pick, and could be a genuine differential.

There’s also huge value in the 7 and below market. Mitoma is the stand-out at 6.5m, and I would back him to improve his finishing in his second season, after a barren run at the end of the last campaign. Richarlison (7m) will be a must-have for me if Kane does leave as a midfielder playing CF, while Sterling (7m) strikes me as a perfect Poch player, given his high work rate and tactical intelligence. He could prove to be massively underpriced if he can steal a starting spot from the army of Chelsea attackers.

Bernardo and Mudryk (6.5m) are also both tempting options, particularly the former, given his strong end to last season. Both are wait-and-sees again for me, however, with one potentially moving to Barca, and the other not guaranteed a starting spot. Sancho (7m) also stands out above Mount and Antony if he finally nails down a regular place in the XI, as I feel he is more likely to be consistently involved in the attacking play than the other two. The obvious caveats apply, not least that he is regularly subbed early.

Harvey Barnes (6.5m) is a perfect Howe player with massive upsides for the price, and would likely be in my team if not for Newcastle’s tricky start to the season. Buendia (6.0m) is a player I really like in the absence of Jacob Ramsey, looking good in pre-season and with a nice set of opening fixtures. Keep a close eye on Brentford’s record signing Kevin Schade (5.5m) too, who could be an OOP striker in the absence of Toney, though Wissa or Mbeumo seem more likely to start the season.

In the bargain basement, the genuinely talented but little-seen Gil and Lo Celso (5.0m) are ones to watchlist, with signs that Postecoglou is likely to give them one last chance at Spurs. Dele (5.0m) will also be worth keeping tabs on with his demons behind him, while Enzo (5.0m) is looking like my new Pereira: a reliable two-pointer who could chip in the odd assist. Of the promoted players, Burnley’s Benson (5.5m) looks a good bet to step up, with a penchant for bangers and 11 goals in 33 games from the wing.

Forwards

Right, so apart from Haaland, who else? There are a number of interesting mid and low-priced options this year, making the second and third fiddle to the Man City man a harder choice than ever. The primary battle in my mind is between Watkins (8m) and the two Chelsea and Liverpool forwards: Nkunku (7.5m) and Jackson (7m), and Darwin and Gakpo (7.5m).

The absence of any rotation risk and a nice run of fixtures makes Watkins the obvious choice for me. Of the Liverpool options, Gakpo seems the most likely Liverpool attacker to start besides Salah, based on his form and starts both last season and in pre-season, but he has less explosive scoring potential than Darwin. 

Jackson and Nkunku have both looked lively in pre-season, but Chelsea remain something of an unknown quantity, as does their precise formation. With Jackson and Nkunku both wide forwards by trade, it remains to see where the goals will fall, with the wingbacks being my immediate preference for safe attacking and defensive returns. The good thing with Watkins is that he’s an easy trade down to any of those players, even if their prices rise.

Beyond them, we get into the budget and enabler bracket. There’s another double dilemma here: Brighton’s Ferguson (6m) and Joao Pedro (5.5m). The money spent on Pedro implies that he is likely to start, but probably out wide, while Ferguson is likely to rotate with or be subbed for Welbeck. Joao Pedro’s form in pre-season and consistently great displays for Watford makes him a strong enabler in my eyes, but not without some rotation and OOP risk. 

Wissa (6m) is a worthy shout for a Toney-less Brentford, and anyone who’s really scraping around might consider Vinicius (5m), who I see as a better Mitrovic replacement (at least initially) than the misfiring Raul Jiménez (5.5m). And since we’re at the very bottom of the barrel – and the article – keep half an eye on Eddie Nketiah (5.5m). His good three weeks might be the first ones.

Published
Categorised as Opinion

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *