It’s probably contrary to the point of an article on anything to declare, first sentence, that you have very little to say about it. I put it down to some sort of writer’s block at first, but the more time I dedicated to sorting through my thoughts and feelings on Alien: Isolation, the more I realised how fleeting they are.
It is some small mercy that I didn’t have to review the game. I would have pumped something out, sure; probably stuck an 8/10 at the end. There’s your badge of merit, Isolation. If you want an opinion falsely distilled into an integer, stop right here. Creative Assembly’s outing is exceptionally and laudably capable.
For those reviewers, though, there are all of the usual issues to contend with – a modest window in which to play, then consider, then write and possibly rewrite a comprehensive study, on a bit of media that offers no opportunity to backtrack beyond saves. But there is something in this particular example that bears itself out in the couple of glaringly negative reviews – IGN’s 59 or Gamespot’s 6/10 among other maxed out scores – and that is the pacing.
Taken as a series of vignettes, the game borders on perfection. If that’s not in its adherence to genre and masterful mechanics – it may be the scariest first person game I’ve played – it achieves an astounding reverence to the original film in a way that perfectly melds with gameplay. The game, notably at 60fps, feels exceptionally cinematic even in its graphical modesty; maybe even because of it. The station is a perfect extension of the 70s space-faring Nostromo, even while aping a tactically lit body or jump scare from the likes of Dead Space and System Shock 2. From tracker to terminals, every bit of technology and angular industrial engineering feeds into a seamless illusion of the series’ anachronistic future.
Your first proper encounter with the xenomorph is brutal, maddeningly so, and the save points cruelly spaced, but 10 hours in and you look back on it with fondness. The Working Joes, sinister marshmallow androids, present some of the finest stealth sections in the game. The flashback segment is perfectly rendered, even as you know before you’ve started exactly how it all ends. Never has a game been better served by a vertical slice – cut in almost anywhere, and you’ll find an hour or two of flawless terror.
But the game is not an hour or two long, it is twenty. I pity those who played it in a mere couple of sittings. I will eschew one criticism – it is not particularly hard if you take on all the means and hints it gives you, although it can occasionally feel cheap. Nor was it the alien that wore me down; he goes all but AWOL for half of the story. The game simply becomes a slog. While the xenomorph hunts you at the start and you have no recourse but to hide in lockers, while the quest markers invariably point you exactly where you do not need to go, you have little choice but to explore the beautiful environments and risk the wrath of the creature that will send you back ten minutes in saves. Infuriating, yes, but tense, magnificently so. There is a real and ever-present danger, one that can be experimented with by distractions and careful study of routes and behaviours, but always at the painful cost of progress.
It is when the alien leaves, and on the early acquisition of the flamethrower, that interest starts to wane even as the stakes are repeatedly raised. Suddenly the perpetual queue of contrivances that drive you to find keycards, start generators and key in codes to pass the door to the next area and next potential route off the station become more transparent, more wearing. Combat supplies are only of any real use in a section where you’re forced to fight, and others are so ample late on as to barely require exploration, beyond what is demanded by your next fetch quest. By belching out six short bursts with the flamethrower, the alien can be driven away for long enough to mash the requisite buttons and move on. Not once did I run out of ammo for it. More is always positioned wherever it’s intended as the natural means to progression, and it just as often works in situations that might have been intended for stealth. I received almost as much as I’d got all game in the last level, in anticipation of a boss fight. All it actually precluded was a few facehuggers in a vent. There is, and I feel righteous in spoiling it, no brave final encounter, no Aliens-esque escape with the monsters nipping at your heels. The game ends with what some might term a suitably understated ending, and what I would call a whimper. It’s a conclusion in full expectation of a sequel, with everything lost and nothing gained; one which tries desperately to emulate its source material but offers nothing of the relief or finality.
All of which is to say very little, very elaborately. What I feel about Isolation lies more in feelings that I can’t transcribe than in traditional criticism. There is still not a great deal to criticise. It plays perfectly; the voice acting is, with the baffling exception of Ripley herself, top notch; the world is a joy to inhabit; and much of it, in doses, is up there with the greatest horror games – and one of the greatest films – ever devised. As twenty hours of a full cinematic experience, it sags. It is partly under the expectation of those first few hours, but just as much down to a sense of frustration and tedium that I can’t decide how they could have remedied. As Sevastopol station collapses, aliens breed and people get picked off, somehow the sense of danger gutters out. Would that the flamethrower had followed suit.
