A ‘statement of intent’. That’s how both Wayne Rooney’s contract extension and Juan Mata’s arrival have been touted: a sign that Manchester United can continue to attract the big players with more than Europa League aspirations.
As I write this, Fellaini has just given the ball away against Crystal Palace. Wilfried Zaha has just been on the end of a 0-4 thumping in Cardiff, and Shinji Kagawa is contemplating a final season at the club without scoring a single goal.
It is a strange league and a strange media climate in which the managers on Merseyside are praised for canny acquisitions, yet Arsenal and United investing obscene amounts into well stocked positions is a magic tonic for success. Our big heaired Belgian was a panic buy, and whatever belief Ozil invested in the Arsenal squad seems to have dissipated as he fails to perform with any consistency.
Arsenal may not have been crying out for another playmaker, but they have catered to his talents. Whatever the reasons for his sharp downturn in form, being played out of position oughn’t be one of them. Over-saturation of central midfield is not so much an issue when that’s where all your goals come from.
Moyes has made no such concessions. Jamie Redknapp is not alone in lamenting Mata’s use on the flanks of the United midfield. Wasted, he says. United fans will want to see him work his magic as that elusive number 10.
Who stands in his way? Wayne Rooney.
Rooney is not a number 10. He moves forward to bring down the crosses for Van Persie. He drops back to defend. He falls into central midfield and pings out Hollywood passes to Valencia, that he might cross to the single United player in the box. What he rarely does is link the play between the midfield and the striker. His goal today was ultimately only the tenth this season in a team hardly awash with them. ‘Putting a shift in’ and tracking back more often comes at the expense of a functional forward line. We have defenders and holding midfielders for a reason.
None of this is to say that Rooney isn’t a good player. But he is indulgent. He plays at no.10 because he wants to, and what Rooney wants, he gets. He’d already doubled his wages after a tiff that saw him almost leave a few years ago, an incident that saw relations with Ferguson decline. He failed to link up effectively with Berbatov, leading to his exile on the bench the season after winning the golden boot. Berbatov, a player whose very principle was to link attacks between the midfield and strikers, left, and Rooney got a pay rise.
When Moyes bought Fellaini, he did so in the knowledge that we didn’t need him. His best spell at Everton was almost in that same no.10 role: using his physical presence and footwork to bring down long passes and cause trouble in and around the penalty area. This is not a position he was ever in contention for at United. Performances as a defensive midfielder were patchy, but as he plays now, it is at the expense of Fletcher, Jones, or even Cleverley. For all the criticism of the latter – and it is justified – if he has a future at United it is in this deeper lying role.
Talking of the blond boy wonder: Cleverley has 19 League appearances so far this season, 16 of which he started. £17m man Kagawa has nine and seven – with only one as the no.10.
When Mata plays poorly on the wing, it’s ‘because he’s wasted there’. When Kagawa has played out on the left, he either ‘isn’t up to the rigours of the League’ or ‘isn’t imposing himself on the game’.
It’s absurdly selective criticism, and it’s cropping up everywhere from Sky to the Guardian. It belies either poor memory or sheer ignorance. That hat-trick aside – one of a few starts at no.10 last year – his berated contributions from the wing this season should have led to half a dozen assists. Talk to most United fans and they would cite brief moves to the middle at the end of games, and that start against Lekerkusen, as the most fluid attacking this season.
http://youtu.be/9VWo15oL7o4
Moyes’ tactics have likewise remained unchanged. Save that one absurd anomaly of a match against Bayer Leverkusen, the crossfest versus Fulham was only the culmination of his usual tactic: get it to Valencia, and get it in the box. It is almost unheard of for a Premier League manager to have no clearly defined strategy or style of play, let alone one competing at the top of the table. All that separates Moyes from Pulis is the pretension of attack-focused football.
True creativity is a pipe dream. Buying Mata for the wing and caving to Rooney’s second sulk, continuing to let him play where he wants, represent little more than a callous attempt to cling to a job. They play for United today not because they fit into a manager’s vision for the future or to fill otherwise vacant roles, but to appease fans baying for blood and for signings.
Moyes has misused existing talent, been bossed by player egos, painted a picture of uncertainty, played for one-goal victories and overseen a team without ideas. Rooney and Mata will see him through until the summer. One can only wonder where he’ll take the club then.
