Classic Review: Mass Effect 3

One of the things I love about reviewing games after they’ve been released is being able to read other reviews. Not to steal content – I find far more creative ways to do that – but to look at how their impressions of the game shape up against yours. The appraisal of one hurried reviewer often doesn’t chime with the experiences of a thousand commenters, for obvious reasons. Collective discussion ekes out the detail and nuances of a game, to the extent that comments under articles can provide a better picture of the game by themselves.

Let me tack on a little more preamble, if you would. The Mass Effect series means a lot to me. I’ve played the first two titles through five times, with some others yet unfinished. Both had their flaws, but they also tried to do something really special, challenging what we understand by and expect from an interactive narrative.

You’re unlikely to be reading this without at least a sense of the furore that has surrounded the ending of the game, so hear this: I won’t be ranting about it. I want to make this as balanced as possible, because on the balance of things, it’s still mightily impressive. People have done anger, incredulity and mournful satire in their droves. What I’m aiming to do here is encapsulate the game in its entirety – what was good, what was bad, and how that’s affected my overarching view of the series.

joker

Regardless of personal opinion, Mass Effect 3 saw the end of a saga marked not just by its attention to detail, scientific plausibility and (ok, subjectively) artful storytelling, but most crucially, its ambition. No game, or certainly none of this type and scope, had ever attempted to integrate so many possible choices across its entire canon, and deliver a resolution for each. Characters were brilliantly developed, romances were tactful. Each player’s Shepard feels like theirs and theirs alone. If you enjoyed the games, they immersed you.

These elements stutter into life in this third outing. The opening segment on Earth, as you might have gathered from my demo review, fails somewhat to capture the gravity of the moment. The voice acting and script here are sub-par, and in the following meet-up with Liara, even more noticeably so; her unflinching coldness, first demonstrated in Shadow Broker, is manifest in both her actions and some horribly wooden speech. That first ‘mission’ after Earth means that the whole introduction plays like a giant tutorial, with plot points drudgingly outlined and Cerberus’ baddie status made apparent.

This isn’t the only early reunion that fails to impress. The meeting with Garrus proves a vital but dull story bridge, most interesting as a showcase for some new, tougher enemies. The trip to the Salarian home world, meanwhile, conspires to be boring even with Wrex and Mordin in tow. Your choice of squad mates is limited at this point, but some of the squad dialogue is inexcusably colourless. The action may be tense and the goals greater than ever, but you expect some light relief and insight from the likes of Garrus that just doesn’t materialise early game.

ME3 mech

All of that said, the vast majority of dialogue is excellent. Shepard’s new found tendency to punctuate conversation with ‘yeah’ and ‘uh huh’ is less than welcome, but the much debated streamlining of choices (you often only have a paragon or renegade – there is no neutral option) does make the patter flow better than ever, with responses tailored to suit any answer you give. There’s some occasional uncertainty when you don’t fancy either option, or worry that you’re going to accidentally flirt with a crew member just by not being a dick, but accusations of a decimated choice system are misplaced; the neutral options were not only largely boring, but in many cases mimicked the paragon.

Part of the reason for the change is the way conversation melds into the new ‘reputation’ bar. The special paragon and renegade choices of previous games are few and far between, so the gauge can seem incidental, but they tend to dictate important choices. This is particularly true of the finale, where (exceedingly cruelly) you pretty much need a full, single coloured bar for the most persuasive and pivotal choices. I took less than ten renegade choices throughout the entire game, and was denied the best paragon dialogue. It’s these parting shots which provide most of the game’s best moments. Deaths almost feel choreographed, with one every few major outings, but you never feel cheated by any of them, and they’re rendered with the utmost poignancy, as well as featuring some bitterly funny last lines.

Ship banter is also even better than before, with crew mates wandering the ship to talk with each other, including some lengthy arguments and joke-telling sessions to overhear. There’s the odd argument in which to mediate, if you’ve downloaded the DLC at least (more on that later), but there’s no lack of shipborne bustle. Between your emails, occasional emissaries from other races, and drunken or ponderous crew mates, there’s always something new to occupy you in mission downtime. It’s wonderfully hectic, and the new ship design suits it – bigger and better designed than ever. The new map system helps too, with indicators as to who is on which floor, although this becomes a niggling annoyance in bigger environments such as the Citadel, when you need to hunt down that last of five contacts. Larger and more intricate level design certainly improves the game’s feel and dynamism, and the price of longer loading times on the Xbox is an acceptable one.

asari on citadel

The Citadel is perhaps the best example of this. Gutted in ME2, it’s back with a relative flourish. You’re still stuck choosing between levels, with no direct crossover as in the first game, but they’re all fairly expansive, and regain much of the vibrancy of the old Presidium. There’s now a dedicated precinct for shops, of which there are many, and you’re constantly stumbling upon new side quests, or encountering bickering couples and worried friends whose conversations you can interject in. By and large they’re simple additions, good for a few reputation points or some pointers for planet scanning, but they’re also really satisfying in a way you don’t usually expect from a game. Obviously it’s great to join someone’s side in an argument and for them to realise who you are, and it keeps your repeated visits interesting. But it’s also nice to play your part on a smaller scale for once, and garner some direct recognition for your efforts over the past two titles.

Of course, there are some bigger quest trails springing from simple conversation. One has you teaming up with another Spectre to find an indoctrinated diplomat, and another ends in an encounter with a familiar Batarian face. This is all instigated via the new Spectre terminal, tucked away in an exclusive area of C-sec, which grants you infallible comms and a means to levy your authority. They’re pretty simple, but the stakes don’t let up. It feels like proper Spectre work, sleuthing with a splash of action, and it’s a shame both that they’re so few and far between, and that the terminal is so woefully underused. Some DLC here is an eminent possibility. As far as other side missions go, there are honestly few to speak of. Worlds to land on are generally tied into the main storyline, whether you intended to find them or not, with all other scanning related to the recovery of objects ‘for the war effort’. With no resources to find or probes to buy this isn’t as menial as in ME2, and provides a welcome change of pace at times, but more could have been (and may yet be) made of it.

The existing DLC, From Ashes, is a worthy addition, although the extra content often seems so integral to the series’ canon that you wonder what the game would be like without it. The mission by which you gain the extra squad mate is barely worth mentioning, but the background information he provides will be revelatory to fans of the series. There are great moments to be had where the character’s matter-of-fact approach and unique insight clash with other squad members, to brilliant effect; the expansion of key plot points and events, as well as general voicing and character, are excellent and worthwhile. Whether it’s worth the amount you pay for it is debatable, considering that the character’s mere presence is facilitated by content already on the disc, but should you have money to burn, burn it.

ME3 Vega

The other characters who pop up also make some worthy contributions. I should advise that, unbeknownst to me, the profile I used had lost Zaeed in the final mission, so I have no idea what impact he has on proceedings. But it’s a credit to the writers – and Bioware’s relative attention to fan feedback – that some of the least liked characters pop up with the best cameos. Jack’s appearance is fantastic in every sense, Miranda’s problems lead to some unexpected solutions, and Samara’s mission manages to be interesting, touching, and really, really creepy. The universe is such a small place that you even stumble into (or receive emails about) some real forgotten faces. Forgive me for spoiling the whole game for you, but you’ll encounter Jenna, the girl you may have saved from Chora’s Den in the first game. That’s the level of familiarity we’re talking about, and these nostalgic inclusions provide another finely fluffed feather in the writers and designers’ caps.

As far as characters that you know intimately go, the bulk of the writing is peerless. Gone is the angst of much of ME2?s dialogue. Garrus is far more refined, and as my personal romance option (Fem Shep, I should point out), he provides some of the finest moments of the game, on par with the series’ best. Mordin’s tale is a tragi-comic tour de force, fittingly concluded by the best mission in the game. EDI’s new ‘platform’ is weird and gratuitous, but allows for some grudgingly brilliant interchanges. And Tali’s reintroduction comes agonisingly late on, but along with Legion, engineers another remarkable moment in a frenetic and enormously enjoyable story.

So much of the game exhibits both the careful planning and reshaping of the series into a perfect finale. The combat, while not perfect, is the best it has ever been. Much has been borrowed from the Gears of War series – the cover mechanics, the new system of reviving squad mates as an alternative to Medi-gel – but to fantastic effect. Running is quicker and you change direction easier, helping you to exploit the larger, multi-tiered environments. Weapons feel punchier and more powerful than before, to the extent that endless corridor shooting and emptying rooms – still a feature – no longer feels like a chore. Much has been made of the new melee attack – a time-delayed, charged alternative to the simple B-tap – with many calling it vastly overpowered. That might be true if you’re playing it on normal. Unless you’re an Infiltrator, you’re wise never to exit cover to bother with it, and even then you’re likely to be flanked or sniped for your trouble. Meanwhile, the return of grenades after a game’s absence is welcome, if not earth shattering (pun most definitely intended). As an Adept I didn’t need them to clear out shield enemies, but they’re certainly helpful with mechs, though the levelled improvements could have been more adventurous.

This is all bolstered by the new weapon modding system, whereby a stock armoury (although far larger and more varied than the previous game) can be widely altered with various purchased or scavenged parts. This can considerably change the stat focus and capabilities of certain weapons, and is fun to mess around with, although with only two slots per weapon, certain upgrades will always take precedent. This and the various armour parts are a neat if underwhelming compromise, a mild improvement on the overbearingly huge amount of customisation in the first game, and far preferable to the dearth of anything in the second. The multi-context cover button means you sometimes exit by accident and get your head shot off, but thankfully, auto saving has also been further refined, and now covers you a little too well. I replayed an hour and a half because I accidentally doomed the Hanar and Drell homeworld. To me, that kind of punishment for split-second actions and bad saving is the mark of a fine game — more because I wanted to replay it than I had to.

ME3 Anderson

In other places, however, it feels like EA deadlines and overwork-induced madness have obliterated considerable promise. I haven’t personally played the segment, but crudely Photoshopping an image of Tali for her ‘big reveal’ is so astonishingly out of character, I can hardly believe it wasn’t the work of a rogue saboteur. But similar problems with the ending, both as a whole and in terms of another stock photo, tell a different story. If you’re starting your Mass Effect experience, they won’t stand out, but having invested yourself emotionally and perfected a character over hundreds of hours, these issues are galling.

More than laziness or copping out, they break the illusion of the universe, that integral element of player immersion. It’s something that the games before it, and the vast majority of this game, do so very well. They tell the story expertly, and more than that, they make you feel as if it’s your own. But the conclusions to so many of your experiences take such unexpected and ludicrous turns that you stop feeling like the architect any more. When you lose the ability to choose and affect your own destiny through the actions you’ve taken, you’re no longer writing the history of Commander Shepard.

The paths thrust upon you – and in defiance of all finale-writing precedent, they do come out of nowhere – not only cease to fit with your preconceptions and sense of the universe you reside in, but stop fitting with your sense of Shepard’s character, and those of your best loved and most well worn companions. They not only neglect and ignore established series lore and previous hints, but make a mockery of your efforts and involvement with the games. Deaths aren’t an issue; the rest of the game shows that. It’s the manner in which they and the broader ending take place, with all its sickening implications and ambiguities, which really grind. And when you know the ending is hopeless, you lose all desire to attain it.

Mass Effect 3 is a fantastic game, but it makes the entire series unplayable.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *