This is the one I tend to boast about, but you’ll have to take my word for it. It was originally included in this Rock Paper Shotgun round-up via Gamer UK, but the link is broken as a result of site downtime. It does include a lengthy quote though, which you’ll find below.
“The cycle cannot be broken. The pattern has repeated itself more time than you can fathom.”
Mantra, indictment, and a segment of a story arc brimming with Lovecraftian wonder: forty years of development distilled down into a single sentence. Forty years which have cemented the industry as a major industry, certainly, but also a creative force; one that’s beginning to challenge the script-writers and showy set pieces of Hollywood, at once erudite and intimate.
It began something like this.
In the beginning, there was Pong
Nolan Bushnell and Ted Dabney, co-founders of pioneering games company Atari, are gaming’s sine qua non. More than just figureheads for the games industry, the men are downright worshipped for creating a market where none essentially existed. The company they founded brought video games not just into bars and buildings country-wide, but into the home.
Few though would consider the studio’s seminal production and endearing classic Pong to be a narrative spectacle. In fact, it has no inherent narrative at all. There are no characters; there is no story. It’s just a bat, some bleeping, and a rectangular ball.
But one of the features of the medium which has distinguished it above all others is the ability to customise your experience. Books and films detail a very particular journey in mesmerising detail, or none at all. Everything in a film is engineered and fine tuned to present the viewer with, well, a set viewpoint.
Yet even in this earliest period of gaming history, when Star Wars was proving its most potent inspiration, interactivity encouraged a notion which lies at the heart of games development to this day: the ability to choose your own story.
Even with Pong, the player was able to project their own story onto the screen. It could be Borg versus McEnroe, Evert against Navratilova. No limits, no adherences. It’s a crude manifestation of narrative, certainly, but this simplest form of interactive entertainment presented – and manifested – possibilities that had never really been there before.
It was a precedent they extended with Asteroids. Here was a kind of ‘character’ you could identify with: an intrepid explorer navigating the (scientifically dodgy) perils of space. You crafted your own adventure. A similar story emerged in the form of Space Invaders, a game so successful that Atari bought the rights to a console version, another milestone.
Tentacular Ruskies
Space Invaders was in keeping with the zeitgeist and great fun to play, but more than that, it gave you something to protect. Whether you were the last bastion of human resistance, or one of a million gunners putting their many lives in your hands, games were steadily probing more complex and weighty ideas. The consumer loved it.
The problem was technology. The lack of computing power meant custom microchips, which (to keep ‘em cheap) prevented any input by the developer beyond the simple mechanics of the game. The consequence was a series of narratives almost entirely of your own invention. They defied all conventional media models. Developers were cottoning onto a feverish obsession with 70s space race fever and Cold War anxiety, but there was no information being disseminated, and no underlying agenda. It was simply there for the consumer to enjoy.
Although corporate and financial wrangling ultimately destroyed the company, that spirit survived. As capabilities increased and the industry became a viable career option, individual creativity burgeoned. The first games were, in essence, born of engineers experimenting with hardware. The slow dissemination of computers and their basic tools, the code of programming languages, led to games with more distinguishable stories and characters. Games like Pac-man.
From the very beginning, Pac-man was intended to diversify the market that games appealed to. Creator Toru Iwatani told gamespot that “[Because an arcade] was not a very inviting atmosphere for female gamers…I wanted to make a game that would be more inviting; to bring in the female users, maybe couples, where boyfriends and girlfriends come in together. That was the basic idea.”
His design nous paid off. Over thirty years later, 94% of Americans still recognised the titular yellow ghost-guzzler. As Marcus Brigstocke notes, running around and eating pills in a dark room with a repetitive soundtrack does seem remarkably prescient, but it wasn’t so much about the story Pac-man told as the way it did it. The simplest of entrepreneurial strategies opened up a myriad different possibilities and prospective audiences, where most games had been either war simulators or fantasy role-plays.
It marked the moment that video games truly transcended their hardcore audience, and forcibly munched their way into the mainstream. The next six years would see the likes of Donkey Kong, Frogger, Dig Dug and Tron, all of which gained immeasurably from a seemingly new-found freedom to target whomsoever they liked. Brooding space trek Metroid inspired a twelve title series with its own rich universe, and also boasts one of the strongest female leads in game history.
That’s not to say that old habits were holding the industry back. Exploration was a great theoretical strength of gaming – most people can’t go cave exploring and treasure hunting, after all. But as noted, technology had always held it back. The arrival of the Nintendo Entertainment System, and a little title called The Legend of Zelda, changed those perceptions irreversibly, and happened to create a universally adored franchise in the process.
A Link to the Future
The mechanics of the games are marvellous, but it’s their creativity which defines them. Unfailingly opening with a young, male hero discovering his destiny and setting out to rescue a princess, story conventions are gleefully turned on their head: the Princess is always older, stronger, entirely unromanceable, and prone to the odd bit of cross-dressing. It’s a world with few competitors, emerging somewhere from the Middle Earth and medieval moulds, but entirely of its own identity.
From the 35 year-old would-be fairy to a girl in love with a goblin, by way of a talking baby that runs its own shop and a race of terrifying chicken/human hybrids, the sixteen official titles are beyond meaningful description. Most extraordinary is their insistance on preserving early limitations, with not a single word of spoken dialogue. The result is an array of sensory experiences rendered with humour, heart and imagination, arguably beyond any film or TV franchise in the modern era.
Narrative’s best moments, admittedly, lie outside of my basic chronology. It’s scarcely true that there weren’t any games for fifteen years which created outstanding narrative experiences. Ultima IV’s systems of morality and choice pre-date similar conventions by decades, 1990’s The Secret of Monkey Island introduced the now-standard concept of a branching dialogue tree, and Infocom boasted a series of incredibly rich stories in their fantasy adventures. But while systems and the quality of writing evolved, established norms did not. The niche adventure market was an outlier in the post-crash console world, where the big players were unable to take the same risks. As marketing took hold of the industry, innovation left the equation.
Day of the Disc
The arrival of the Playstation in 1994 was to the industry what Pac-man had been some fifteen years prior – a reason to be taken seriously. It was a machine which, through savvy marketing, facilitated a variety of games for a variety of people. CDs meant it was cheaper to develop for and produce than the rival Nintendo 64, which meant more games. More games meant more choice, and more choice meant more consumers. The CD drive also got it into peoples’ homes as an audio player at the forefront of the digital revolution, a trick the company would copy with DVDs in the PS2 and Blu-ray in the PS3, to varying degrees of success.
What it offered in creativity, it lacked in nuance. Discriminate marketing meant girls had their Barbie games, boys had their shooters, and the grown-ups had their horror titles, such as the heavily film inspired (but creatively rendered) Resident Evil series. The odd game or series would jump out from the pack, such as the darkly beautiful OddWorld, the terrifying powerlessness of supernatural-horror Silent Hill, or the newly exclusive Final Fantasy’s, with their emotionally affecting twists beyond the age of most of its players. But these became blips among bland shovelware and polished but unadventurous sequels.
So it remained for another generation.
The personal computer, ever the front-line of experimental geekery, developed a little differently. The previously name-dropped Ultima and the Infocom crowd were born and bred on the PC. As computers became more uniform to develop on with the emergence of Microsoft as a dominant force, so games became bigger and better, and so coders and programmers became more attuned to great game development.
The culmination of years of basement film marathons and unrivalled technical prowess was in the slew of great science fiction titles of the 90s and early 2000s. System Shock, Half Life and Deus Ex, while borrowing heavily from the works of Ridley Scott in particular, are franchises which continue to this day in some form or another, and truly rival their source material in the stories and characters they develop.
Meanwhile, ex-Macintosh developer (and recent Microsoft acquisition) Bungie was making waves with its 2001 Xbox release Halo: Combat Evolved, a relatively creative but fabulously constructed take on the space marine trope, and a Canadian studio called Bioware was emerging as inheritor-elect to Infocom’s storytelling and interactivity crown. As far as computers went, games were getting smarter, tighter and more interesting, but not really more imaginative.
Sandbox stylings
The next generation of console and computer hardware changed all this. Halo hinted at the promise of the platforms early on, but it was a game by British studio Rockstar which would alter what we expect from an interactive narrative. Its name was Grand Theft Auto 3.
The series had its beginnings on the Playstation and PC, but the scale of its map and active bustle of the cityscape forced it into a top-down perspective, retro even for the time. Yet with the new hardware afforded by the Playstation 2 et al, the kinds of fully-functioning, reactive, sandbox worlds teased by technical marvels such as Ocarina of Time were now fully realisable. And fully realised it was. Rarely had a game actively encouraged you to deviate from its central story, with clothes and properties to purchase, fully-fleshed radio stations to tune into, and yes, plenty of people to kill.
It didn’t just have an engrossing storyline and a hefty cast of established voice actors, nor simply cutting consumerist parodies and cinematic camera deployment. It was the way in which it felt like an extension of the real world. To some this was inspired; to others, utterly unnerving. It became the first of a slew of fantastical scenario simulators like Fallout 3 and the Elder Scrolls games, which allowed the player infinite variables in their character’s journey.
Square one
Little has really changed since. Games are still experimenting with established movie techniques, with the differences between the two media giants still so pronounced. The very attributes which define and shape the experiences of those open world games also hinder their narrative delivery; fulfilling side quests with hours of dungeon diving inevitably dilute character and story development.
“The cycle cannot be broken. The pattern has repeated itself more time than you can fathom. Organic civilisations rise, evolve, advance. And at the apex of their glory, they are extinguished. We impose order on the chaos of organic evolution. You exist because we allow it. And you will end because we demand it.”
So unfolded the pivotal scene in Bioware’s choice-driven space opera Mass Effect; an award-winning series which catered to every gender and sexual orientation, and carried choices through the course of three games – but heavily criticised for a single, tightly scripted conclusion. In the chaos of game narrative’s evolution, it would seem that striking the balance between choice and linear presentation has become its definitive challenge.






