If 2017 was a tough slog through the real world, the virtual world has more than compensated. From the satirical, self-reflective sting of Resident Evil 7 in January through to the pastoral thrills of Xenoblade Chronicles 2 in December, we’ve seen multiple GOTY contenders on an almost monthly basis.
My backlog is pretty extensive, and includes a number of serious GOTY noms elsewhere. With no Horizon, Nier, What Remains of Edith Finch or Persona 5 to choose from, here are my personal top 5 games of 2017 – and one title I’d rather not have got around to.
-
Super Mario Odyssey

In a year where the nostalgic Sonic Mania far exceeded its 3D cousin, Super Mario Odyssey is almost cruelly good. The presence of 2D sections, easter eggs and other throwbacks nods towards its storied past, before glibly plunging you into a glorious future.
It would be enough that Odyssey brings together the tight controls of Mario 64, the exploration of Sunshine and the kinetic joy of Galaxy. What’s even more remarkable is how it stamps its own authority on the Mario formula.
It’s a game made with an absolute clarity of vision, and deservedly unbridled confidence. You can control a dinosaur in the game’s second level, and it’s only uphill from there.
Nintendo use up and throw away ideas so freely in Odyssey that it starts to feel like they’re trolling other developers. Go on, come and have a go if you think you’re good enough. Try and make something this effortlessly fun, this content rich, this fucking polished.
Taking cosmetic microtransactions – the “good kind” of microtransactions – and using 100% in-game collectable currency is simply the coup de grâce. It’s a dazzling, open-hearted riposte to a certain kind of thinking. Modern games can be made this way.
In the wake of the Battlefront 2 fiasco, this is an almost mocking flourish. It’s an act of ultimate generosity from a developer at the peak of their powers. Nintendo are swimming against the tide, and doing so with astounding grace.
Where other platform games turn a single idea into a rollercoaster ride, Odyssey is an entire theme park. Nintendo and Disney have always shared a certain ethos, committing to principles and techniques through thick and thin. in 2017, Nintendo hit the highest Disney standard, and produced a pure sensory delight.
2. XCOM 2: War of the Chosen

HoMM3. Civ 4. Shogun 2. XCOM 2: War of the Chosen sits comfortably among the shining greats of the turn-based strategy genre. This is the agony and the ecstasy of life, love, loss and giant lasers, in pure tablet form. I have played this far more than Breath of the Wild, and I expect that trend to continue.
This abundantly generous expansion of an already great game may lay it on too thick for newcomers, clunkily combining with the game’s existing DLC and fudging its story. Complaints linger too about the base game’s mission timers, though WOTC adds variety in both attack and defence.
Come to this game-sized expansion after a vanilla XCOM 2 playthrough, however, and you will be richly rewarded. More customisation, more bad guys, more allies, more weapons, more maps, a better UI – and more Ironman resets. It’s never felt so good to be so devastated.
3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild

Mario is often cited as Nintendo’s biggest franchise, but it’s one they’ve been unafraid to tinker and toy with – be it with weird Gameboy tennis RPGs, Smash Football’s pelvis-thrusting Waluigi, or Rabbids’ shotgun-wielding Peach.
By contrast, the Zelda canon has hewn pretty closely to its 1990s format. The dungeons got longer and the items more numerous, but the structures and enemies persisted. Majora’s Mask and Wind Waker, both brave and interesting steps forward, arrived to middling sales and fan scepticism. Two devoutly traditional console sequels followed, with diminishing returns.
I worried when Nintendo mentioned Skyrim as a source of inspiration for Breath of the Wild. Like Dragon Age: Inquisition before it, the sudden move to an open-world setting seemed an ill fit, driven more by market forces and a poorly received predecessor than what the devs truly wanted. The result still beggars belief, even if it shouldn’t, given the calibre of its creators.
Breath of the Wild isn’t a complete reinvention of the open world wheel – Witcher 3 and MGS V surely represent incremental steps – but it is a more perfect translation of the Zelda formula than could ever be expected.
How to describe the loving detail in every area; the verticality and traversal options that encourage you not to fast travel; the interlocking elemental systems; or the sheer pastoral beauty of post-apocalypse Hyrule? To put it bluntly, it makes Bethesda’s most recent efforts look very dated indeed.
Some elements have been cloned from its Western inspirations – the horse, largely useless – and some lessons still stand to be learned. A few more quests and a little more structure wouldn’t go amiss; nor some grander and more intricate dungeons.
But Nintendo have made an open world game where exploring the world is more beguiling than following the story. They’ve remade Zelda 2, and that might be the bravest decision of all.
4. Prey

If you were nominating for a Steam-style ‘Criminally Underrated Award’, Prey would win it hands down. This is the modern sequel System Shock 2 deserved: a deceptively smart, deftly written and beautifully voiced game, with an introduction to rival its famous forebear.
Prey’s other influences are very much worn on its sleeve. Its retro aesthetic apes Alien Isolation, the narrative structure is arguably cribbed from BioShock, and the gunplay and powers are Dishonored off-cuts. The tropes are well worn, even if the execution isn’t.
Yet none of this is ever distracting. Talos 1 is as coherent and beguiling a hub world as you could ever wish for, and a setting to rival that of Rapture. From the environmental storytelling and logs trailing each death – you can track down every single member of the crew, or what’s left of them – to the central yarn of the enigmatic family Yu, Prey delivers on almost every front.
Minor frustrations with enemy repetition and a standard weapon roster are only glancing impacts, massively overstated by some reviewers. This is a remarkably powerful, atmospheric and endearing game, with far better crafting and RPG elements than any of the games that inspired it. Its sales indicate a cult classic in the making, but I’m praying for a sequel.
5. Splatoon 2

There are many reasonable criticisms of Splatoon 2. Most of them – the sub par matchmaking experience, or the relative similarity to the first game – are not really Splatoon 2’s fault. Nintendo and the Switch are clearly not ready for a game of Call of Duty or PUBG’s scale. Pinning the faults of the father on the prodigal son, though?That’s just a little bit churlish.
Splatoon 2 is nothing less than the Toy Story 2 of games. This is everything you could ever want in a sequel. Nintendo have fine-tuned (or should that be tuna-d?) the core formula of Splatoon – paint as much of the map with your team’s colour as possible – while liberally sloshing on new weapons and game modes.
The horde mode-esque Salmon Run is a brilliant addition, and another demonstration of Nintendo’s ability to revitalise tired concepts. But really, Splatoon 2 is best praised for bringing its unique brand of multiplayer to the masses.
The Inkopolis Plaza with its community generated messages; the gloriously silly, voice chatless games; the quickfire matches; and the sheer majesty of Splatfests, settling the defining issues of our age. In spite of its frustrations, there simply isn’t anything else like Splatoon 2. If Nintendo ever sorts out online play, CoD is getting cooked.
Honourable Mention – Resident Evil 7

The Force Awakens of the Resi series. That pretty much sums up both the importance and the end result with Resident Evil 7. Expectations may not have been particularly high, but the series still meant something. Botch this, and you don’t just lose a brand: the commercial viability of big budget horror would arguably have gone with it.
It’s understandable then that Resi 7 is a greatest hits compilation. Copying many of the beats of the first game – re-released to great fanfare in the interim – Resi 7 managed to breathe new life into old ideas. An interesting central cast of characters managed to illuminate a space that, on the face of it, seemed far smaller in scope and possibilities than the past few entries.
Resi 7 is safe, yes, but no less effective for it. There are stumbles in the dark, and a few missed shots – bullet-spongy bosses, uninspired enemy designs, and a decidedly naff ending among them. But the familiar beats bore a certain amount of nostalgia, relief, and hope for the future. Resi is a survival horror franchise again, and that’s more than enough to get people excited.
Biggest Letdown – Dishonored 2

Ok, this didn’t come out in 2017, but it is my most disappointing experience of the year. The original Dishonored was a surprise hit – a superpower based game with meaty, fluid combat, solid stealth mechanics, and a vivid world of Victorian caricatures. True to Bethesda’s form, however, the story was a major letdown. Celebrity voice actors were wasted, and combat was hampered by a poorly judged morality system.
It’s a shame then that Dishonored 2 doubles down on everything the first game did wrong – and only some of the things it did right. The worlds are far larger, with more pockets to explore and collectables to obtain. But the tightness of controls seems to have been sacrificed on this altar. Blinks often fail to hit their targets, drop assassinations are extremely hit and miss, and vision cones seem far more arbitrary. Stand on a low roof and you might not be seen from the ground; stand on a far higher lamppost and you will be.
The story is similarly poor, but the potential makes it markedly more offensive. The premise, involving a coup against Empress Emily Kaldwin, allows you to control either the young ruler or her ageing father. Logically, these two experiences should be markedly different. Corvo’s age should impede his brutish, athletic moveset, and Emily should provoke interesting interactions, experiencing a very different life outside the palace. The narrative tension in either case is interesting, and the possibilities myriad.
It shouldn’t be a surprise that they play and act almost identically. In some ways, it’s hard to blame the developers. Doing both justice would require the resources of two games. But if you can’t do it properly, why do it at all? Commit to Emily as the protagonist, and you have the amended moveset with a fascinating new character; a grieving princess raised by a mythical killer.
Write generically enough to suit both plotlines, and your story is castrated. Interactions with your people are limited to two NPCs and a few lines of morality-inflected dialogue. Both Emily and Corvo reflect that they have neglected their empire, but the new Empress is worse. They promise to do better, but the post-game is a slideshow, and the villain comically evil. We don’t get to see the change, and we don’t see any evidence that they’ve learned anything. The two characters should not have the same status or expectations, yet almost nothing differs in their approach to challenges, or the reactions of the people who see them.
The dialogue, even by the first game’s standards, is uniformly atrocious. Exposition is front-loaded, and lines are clipped and cut across each other. Characters make sure to bring up integral plot details at every possible opportunity. Audio diaries record at least a dozen people being murdered or kidnapped by moustache twirling, monologuing villains, while requiring you to stand next to the audio source for the entire duration.
Even the audio mixing is appalling, with NPCs muttering gibberish under their breaths at the same level as regular dialogue. And, true to form, the famous names are entirely wasted. Narcos’ Pedro Pascal appears in a throwaway, thumbnail sketch role, as do Rosario Dawson and Sam Rockwell. Vincent D’Onofrio has the measure of the script, and gives a suitably terrible performance.
There is something wonderful in the world that the two Dishonored games conjure, and the sequel is occasionally illuminated. The Clockwork Mansion (where rooms swap themselves out with working mechanisms and maintenance sub levels) and Stilton’s Manor (where you can peer into and alter the past and future) are dazzlingly inventive, to the extent that many people defend the game on their strength alone. Fifteen years ago, this kind of game would be a mid-tier effort with a more limited scope, and more realistic ambitions. Stretched to feature length and breadth, it fails to sustain itself.
Fellow French developer DONTNOD made their debut with Remember Me. The game’s central time shifting mechanic was superb, but under-utilised, and the game was propped up with an undercooked combat system, and lines like “This Little Red Riding Hood’s got a basket full of kickass”. They followed it up with Life is Strange, a genre masterpiece. Arkane followed up 2016’s Dishonored 2 with 2017’s Prey. Your honour, the prosecution rests.
